Federal rules require a train to start sounding its horn 15 to 20 seconds before it reaches a public crossing, at between 96 and 110 decibels. Pleasanton has four of those crossings on one Union Pacific line through the middle of town, and every freight train and every ACE commuter train sounds that pattern at each one.
On Monday, Nov. 2, at 6 p.m., the City will hold a neighborhood meeting at the Pleasanton Public Library, 400 Old Bernal Avenue, to go over the recommended improvements for a Railroad Quiet Zone. For most of the past year, the project was discussed as an affordable fix. The City's latest update points somewhere else. Monday's meeting will be the first public look at how much quiet costs, and that figure will shape how soon the horns stop.
Four Crossings, Very Different Traffic
The study area is small and specific. The City's consultant request names four public crossings and lists average daily traffic for each:
| Crossing | Average daily vehicle trips |
|---|---|
| Santa Rita Road | 18,600 |
| St. Mary's Street | 5,100 |
| Rose Avenue | 1,400 |
| West Angela Street | 700 |
Santa Rita Road carries more than 26 times the traffic of West Angela Street. Even so, a quiet zone has to cover every crossing in the corridor, so both get the same federal risk analysis. The consultant's job is to run the Federal Railroad Administration's calculator and decide what supplemental safety measures each crossing needs to qualify. Those measures could be raised medians that stop drivers from going around lowered gates, or something heavier. The answer drives the cost, and the cost drives the schedule.
Who Is Sounding the Horn, and When
According to the City, Union Pacific runs three to four freight trains a day on the single track through Pleasanton, and ACE runs eight trains on weekdays. ACE's published schedule shows when the commuter trains leave the Pleasanton station at 4950 Pleasanton Avenue:
- Westbound, mornings: 5:23, 6:48, 7:53 and 8:45 a.m.
- Eastbound, afternoons and evenings: 3:08, 4:28, 5:28 and 6:28 p.m.
The 5:23 a.m. departure is the one that wakes people up, and the freight trains run on their own timetable outside the commuter windows. In June 2025, Pleasanton Weekly reported that residents told the City Council that increased ACE service and horns at all hours were affecting families nearby. Speakers described lost sleep and the noise reaching downtown businesses and visitors, and they asked the City to pay for a feasibility study.
A quiet zone has limits. Under the federal train horn rule, it ends only the routine horn pattern at crossings. Engineers can still sound the horn in emergencies and for other safety reasons.
How a Petition Became a Capital Project
The push came from residents. By April 2025, a petition started by resident Jim Lehrman had 229 supporters, Pleasanton Weekly reported. By December, it had more than 400 signatures, and Lehrman declared victory after the Council acted.
The City moved in three steps:
- Aug. 19, 2025: The City Council created the Railroad Quiet Zone as Capital Improvement Program project 26510.
- Oct. 15, 2025: The City issued a request for proposals for a design consultant.
- Dec. 16, 2025: The Council approved a $168,858 agreement with Kimley-Horn and Associates. Pleasanton Weekly reported that the contract was paid for with surplus funds from the Bernal synthetic turf repair and replacement project, and that construction would need its own approval and funding.
The money spent so far pays for design. Gates, medians and signals are a separate expense, and the City's request for proposals said construction funding had not been allocated.
The Cost Estimate Has Changed Before
The price of quieting these four crossings has shifted several times.
From 2007 to 2017, City staff looked at four-quadrant gates and estimated about $500,000 per crossing, or roughly $2 million in total. The idea was set aside because of cost. In 2018, a consultant working for ACE sketched a cheaper concept with median islands at all four crossings. ACE stopped that work before consulting Union Pacific or the FRA, after it dropped a service-expansion effort.
In its June 2025 coverage of residents' appeals to the Council that spring, Pleasanton Weekly reported a feasibility consultant estimate of about $175,000 and total implementation of $50,000 to $500,000 or more, depending on the crossings and the safety work required. As recently as Oct. 20, 2026, PleasantonCA.city's report on the meeting said the City expected medians or similar designs costing roughly a tenth of the old $2 million figure, and that a heavier design would need more money and another Council approval.
The City's project page, updated Oct. 22, includes this status note:
"Review of railroad crossing upgrades required by California Public Utilities Commission, Union Pacific Railroad and the Federal Railroad Administration has been completed. Extensive upgrades would be required to implement the quiet zone."
That sentence comes from the agencies that have to approve the crossings, and it is the most recent official statement on the project. The City has not yet posted crossing-by-crossing recommendations or a construction estimate. The meeting listing went up Oct. 14, and as of Oct. 20, no agenda or presentation was attached. Monday is when those details become public.
What Neighboring Quiet Zones Took
Two nearby quiet zones on the same corridor show that the bigger version of this project can take longer and cost more.
Sunol, just west through Niles Canyon, got its quiet zone in June 2018 after more than four years of work among the community, Alameda County and the railroad, according to the community site Inform Sunol. The work kept going after that. A June 2021 ACE rail commission board packet describes revisions made in response to public concerns, including a redesigned four-quadrant gate at Sunol's Main Street that was still being coordinated with the County.
Fremont finished construction at Niles and Nursery Avenue in July 2021, submitted its Notice of Establishment in August, and started the quiet zone on Sept. 4, 2021. The City of Fremont reports final design and construction costs of $3 million there, for a safety need first identified in a 2012 report. Fremont also has a quiet zone at Stevenson Boulevard.
Pleasanton's plan follows Sunol's model, PleasantonCA.city reported. A $3 million crossing in Fremont and four-quadrant gate revisions in Sunol give a sense of the cost and time involved once a review calls for extensive work.
After Monday: The Steps Before the Horns Stop
The City says the whole process should take about two years to design, review, build and activate. After the Nov. 2 meeting, staff will take the recommended changes and public comments to the City Council and ask for direction in December 2026 or January 2027.
After that, the federal process has fixed steps. The City's request for proposals describes a notice-of-intent stage that includes a 60-day comment period for the railroads. The Notice of Establishment, which is what actually ends routine horn use, comes only after the safety improvements are installed under a separate construction agreement.
The earlier best-case estimate put construction between January and September 2027, depending on how quickly Union Pacific, ACE and the FRA signed off. That estimate came out last December, before the review called for extensive upgrades. Lehrman told The Independent at the time that the work would take "the better part of two years," according to PleasantonCA.city's Oct. 20 report. No activation date has been set.
At the library Monday evening, residents can ask what treatment each of the four crossings needs, what the construction estimate is, where the money would come from, and whether the January to September 2027 window still holds now that the review is complete. Those answers will feed the Council's direction this winter.
Here at Dudum Real Estate Group, we keep up with the projects that change everyday life in Pleasanton. If you'd like to talk about how the plans for Santa Rita Road, St. Mary's Street, Rose Avenue and West Angela Street develop after the Nov. 2 meeting, our Tri-Valley agents would be glad to hear from you. Get Started.